Butter Chicken vs Tikka Masala: Which Should You Order?
October 18, 2026 · 4 min read · The Namak Kitchen
They look nearly identical in the bowl. They're not the same dish. Here's the real difference and how to pick.
The most common question at our host stand, and the answer is genuinely useful because the two dishes suit different people.
Butter chicken (murgh makhani)
- Base: tomato, butter, cream. Very little onion.
- Taste: mildly sweet, silky, smooth. Smoky underneath, because the chicken is cooked in the tandoor before it goes into the gravy.
- Heat: low. Mild by nature.
- Texture: velvety and uniform. The gravy is often blended.
- Origin: Moti Mahal, Delhi, 1950s — invented to revive leftover tandoori chicken.
Chicken tikka masala
- Base: onion *and* tomato, more ground spice, less cream.
- Taste: spicier, tangier, more complex. The onion gives it depth rather than sweetness.
- Heat: medium as standard, and it takes heat well.
- Texture: slightly coarser gravy with visible onion and pepper.
- Origin: disputed. Glasgow claims it; Punjab claims it.
The overlap that confuses everyone
Both start with chicken tikka — boneless chicken marinated in yogurt and spice, charred in the tandoor. That's the shared step. What differs is the gravy it lands in: cream-and-butter versus onion-and-spice.
Which should you order?
- First time eating Indian food? Butter chicken.
- Bringing kids? Butter chicken.
- Find most Indian food at American restaurants too sweet? Tikka masala.
- Want to taste actual spices? Tikka masala.
- Want the one thing that will make everybody at the table happy? Butter chicken.
- Ordering two dishes? Get tikka masala and something from the tandoor, not both of these — they'll taste too similar side by side.
What to eat with them
Both want garlic naan to scoop with and basmati rice underneath. Add raita if you ordered the tikka masala hot.
And the third option nobody expects
Chicken karahi. Seared in the pan with tomato, ginger and green chili, cooked down until the sauce clings. If you like tikka masala, karahi is the dish you graduate to. It's what most of our Pakistani regulars order.
All three are on our menu at The Namak, 848 Willow Ave, Hercules. Order pickup, reserve a table, or ask us what to get.
Come eat with us
The Namak · 848 Willow Ave, Hercules, CA 94547. Halal Indian & Pakistani cooking — dine in, pickup, catering across the East Bay, and a banquet hall for up to 200. Closed Mondays.
Keep reading
- Best Questions to Ask Your Server at an Indian RestaurantEight questions that get you a better meal — and one to avoid, because it tells your server nothing.
- How to Reheat and Store Indian Restaurant LeftoversCurry is better the next day. Naan and biryani need help. Here's how to handle each one properly.
- Indian Food Allergies and Dietary Restrictions: What to KnowWhere dairy, nuts, gluten and mustard actually hide on an Indian menu — and how to order safely.
- Best Indian Restaurant Dishes for Sharing with FriendsThis cuisine was built for a communal table. Here's what to order for a group of six, eight, or twenty.